GoodFellas pizzeria of SunnySide

Michael Stockman Edited 2 months ago

Im a fan for sure, this place as well as the LIC location. I just go for a hot fresh cheese pizza each time, order, wait, open box and eat within 5 min. The only way to eat legit pizza and this fits the bill. I don't know about any lunch specials but the fresh made is worth every effort! Thanks Goodfellas! ++**UPDATE**++ I have eaten here several times since my initial review and here I am taking time to update how great this pizza is. Again I always order as whole pie and if you are taking out and heading home to eat this, jeesh spring for a whole pie is such a great value and reheats very well. The sauce is great slightly sweet and generously applied, crust on point and the cheese is gooey and buttery everything you might want. I have eaten the competition in the area and I will tell you one thing. When you just simply pick up the box when your order is completed you know you have a winner with this pizza. The others make you wonder if there's a whole pizza in there or just a slice. Goodfellas open weekdays is a sure thing but it will leave you sad on weekends when you can't get it. Everyone deserves a break though.

Donton a year ago

I can only speak from my personal experience and maybe I’ll be back to be completely sure but here we go: The pizza was as shown when I took 2 slices and a drink to go. $6 lunch special can’t beat the price, but you get what you pay for. Pizza is very average, thin crust but a bit too thin, cheese very runny and slice greasy. Crust was really good though. Overall flavor was just average, not a “Dying to come back to” spot but the guys are nice and service was good (aside from how my pizza was packaged but its cool) If this is the standard though that some in the reviews see as “Best pizza” contender then my personal experience aside I think yall need a drug test. Try it yourself for your own experience, like I said maybe it was an off day but so far this is definitely not anything remotely crazy

Jesus Torres a year ago

It’s my Go to Pizza Spot. Even since I knew about this place I don’t eat at other pizzerias. This place has great pizza at a great price. Greatly recommend the Margarita slice it’s super juicy and crispy. The customer service is top notch and the place is very welcoming.

The Lorac 2 years ago

GOOD FELLAS MAKING GOOD PIZZA! Got a regular and a pepperoni slice for just $7 total. The guy who was working there was super friendly, funny, and nice! Definitely a “good fella” 😂 Will definitely come back!

Hsin Yi Wei 5 years ago

The decor of Goodfellas Pizza is humble as typical pizza spots in the neighborhood but also clean & bright. The owner was super friendly, welcoming and introduced everything in details. There is a good variety of flavors and we had 2 slices of original cheese & tomato pizza, 1 slice of meat lover deep dish and 1 slice of chicken ranch pizza with 2 Diet Cokes to share for dinner. The pizza was overall decent with a great amount of ingredients.